Graeter's Ice Cream Menu
34 items · $1.50 – $34.95 · Ice Cream Shop in Cincinnati, OH
Graeter's Ice Cream’s menu lists 34 dishes and drinks. Prices range from $1.50 to $34.95, and a typical item costs about $6.75. Popular choices include Turtle Sundae, Cookie Monster, Double Classic Sundae, Traditional Classic Sundae, and Double Scoop Waffle Cone.
Item-Menu 34
- Turtle Sundae$6.75
Hot fudge, pecans, and butterscotch over Vanilla Bean ice cream.
- Cookie Monster$7.75
Cookie Dough and Cookies & Cream ice creams, hot fudge and chocolate sprinkles
- Double Classic Sundae$7.75
Includes one topping, whipped cream and a cherry with two scoops
- Traditional Classic Sundae$6.75
Includes one topping, whipped cream and a cherry
- Double Scoop Waffle Cone$7.25
Cones/Dishes
- Medium Milkshake 20oz$7.00
Frozen Drinks
- Frozen Drinks$7.00
Frozen Drinks
- Pints$6.99
Freezer Cling
- Double Scoop Dish$6.25
Cones/Dishes
- Single Scoop Waffle Cone$5.75
Cones/Dishes
- Traditional Dish$5.25
Cones/Dishes
- Big Scoops$4.75
4.5oz cups ice cream available in these flavors: Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip Double Chocolate Chip Mint Chocolate Chip Madagascar Vanilla Bean
- Ice Cream Cakes$34.95
We take one of our freshly baked yellow or chocolate 8" round cakes and slice it through the middle. In between, we place over one pound of irresistible Graeter's ice cream. We finish it off with a layer of homemade topping and surround the
- Ice Cream Pies$34.95
Our pies are made with a 9-inch chocolate graham cookie crust filled with nearly two pounds of our ice cream, capped with one of our homemade toppings and trimmed with a gourmet blend frosting. All cakes and pies will comfortably serve 10-1
- 56 oz$19.99
56 oz. ice cream
- Chip Wheelies$4.75
Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Kid's Sundae$5.75
- Major League Sundae$6.75
Featured
- 1870 Tower$7.25
Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip ice cream, chocolate bundt cake, hot fudge, fresh whipped cream, pecans and a cherry
- Brownie Sundae$7.25
Featured
- Banana Split$8.00
Featured
- Large Double Dip Soda 24 oz$6.50
Frozen Drinks
- Medium Double Dip Soda 20oz$6.00
Frozen Drinks
- Large Milkshake 24oz$7.50
Frozen Drinks
- Small Milkshake 16oz$6.50
Frozen Drinks
- Specialty Sundae$6.75
Sundaes
- Single Scoop Sugar Cone$4.75
Cones/Dishes
- Double Scoop Sugar Cone$6.25
Cones/Dishes
- Double Scoop Sprinkle Deluxe$8.00
Cones/Dishes
- Single Scoop Sprinkle Deluxe$6.50
Cones/Dishes
- Double Scoop Chocolate Dip$7.75
Cones/Dishes
- Double Scoop Choc Dipped Waffle Cone$7.75
Cones/Dishes
- Single Scoop Specialty Choc Dip$6.25
Cones/Dishes
- Extra Scoop$1.50
Cones/Dishes
How these prices compare
Based on 23 menus with 394 priced items from ice cream shops in Ohio, the median menu item costs $6.50, and half of all items are priced between $4.00 and $8.34.
At Graeter's Ice Cream the median listed price is $6.75, close to the typical $6.50 for ice cream shops in Ohio.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Banana Split | $8.00 | $8.00 |
Typical prices are calculated from 23 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.